Italy passes controversial bill to shield Israel from criticism
Italy's parliament has approved controversial legislation to combat antisemitism, drawing sharp criticism from human rights advocates who warn that adopting an internationally disputed definition could blur the distinction between anti-Jewish hatred and legitimate criticism of Israel and its policies.
The bill passed its final parliamentary hurdle on Tuesday, securing 147 votes in favor, 93 against and five abstentions in the Lower House.
Although presented as a measure to tackle antisemitism, the legislation has raised concerns that it could provide political cover for Israel by allowing criticism of its policies and treatment of Palestinians to be portrayed as antisemitic.
The legislation formally references the working definition of antisemitism adopted by the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance (IHRA), including examples that critics say could be used to stigmatize legitimate political opposition to Israeli policies and Zionism.
The measure does not introduce new criminal offenses or penalties. Instead, it establishes principles for implementing Italy's existing strategy against antisemitism. However, critics argue that embedding the IHRA definition in legislation could have far-reaching consequences for freedom of expression, particularly in universities and public debate.
The controversy has intensified since Hamas' October 7, 2023, operation against Israel and the subsequent Israeli genocidal war on Gaza, which has prompted widespread international condemnation of Israel's military campaign and fueled debate over attempts to equate criticism of Israeli actions with antisemitism.
Mario Venezia, president of Rome's Shoah Museum Foundation and a supporter of the legislation, defended the measure, arguing that criticism of the Israeli government remains legitimate but questioning Israel's existence is a different matter.
Venezia maintained that the legislation would not criminalize criticism of Israeli government policies, noting that proposals for criminal sanctions had been removed during parliamentary discussions.
However, Amnesty International Italy has strongly questioned the decision to incorporate the IHRA definition into the legislation.
Anneliese Baldaccini, the organization's senior head of lobbying and policy, said the main concern was that the law tied its proposed activities and measures to the IHRA definition.
Amnesty has long opposed the definition, warning that some of its accompanying examples could be interpreted in ways that undermine internationally protected freedom of expression and restrict political debate about Israel and the Palestinians.
Critics have particularly highlighted cases at universities abroad where the definition has allegedly been invoked to suppress pro-Palestinian activism and discussions about Israeli policies.
The IHRA definition describes antisemitism as "a certain perception of Jews, which may be expressed as hatred toward Jews." Its accompanying examples include denying Jewish people the right to self-determination, comparing Israeli policies with those of Nazi Germany and holding Jews collectively responsible for Israel's actions.
Opponents of the definition argue that these examples risk conflating hostility toward Jewish people with opposition to Israel's political ideology and state policies.
Many instead support the 2021 Jerusalem Declaration on Antisemitism, developed by scholars specializing in antisemitism and Holocaust studies, including Israeli academics. The declaration explicitly distinguishes antisemitism from legitimate political positions, stating that support for boycotts of Israel, criticism of Zionism as a form of nationalism and evidence-based criticism of Israeli policies are not inherently antisemitic.
The parliamentary approval comes amid a reported increase in antisemitic incidents in Italy. The CDEC Foundation's Antisemitism Observatory recorded 963 incidents in 2025, approximately 10 percent more than in 2024, more than twice the figure recorded in 2023 and five times the 2022 total.
The legislation has also exposed divisions within Italy's center-left opposition, reflecting a broader international dispute over efforts to combat antisemitism without suppressing criticism of Israel, particularly amid continuing international outrage over the suffering of Palestinians in Gaza.
While thousands of institutions and organizations worldwide, including the US State Department, major corporations and universities, have adopted the IHRA definition, its critics continue to warn that its use in legislation and institutional policies risks turning opposition to Israeli state practices into grounds for accusations of antisemitism. (ILKHA)
LEGAL WARNING: All rights of the published news, photos and videos are reserved by İlke Haber Ajansı Basın Yayın San. Trade A.Ş. Under no circumstances can all or part of the news, photos and videos be used without a written contract or subscription.
The Hamas Movement has held Israeli occupation authorities fully responsible for the safety of Palestinian female prisoners at Damon Prison, condemning reported physical assaults and forced removal of their hijabs as a grave violation of their rights, dignity and religious freedom.
Afghan religious scholars and participants at a scientific conference in Kabul have conferred the title of “Sheikh-ul-Islam” on Sheikh Hibatullah Akhundzada, leader of the Islamic Emirate of Afghanistan, as he addressed the gathering on unity, Islamic governance and national stability.
Millions of children worldwide face a future marked by conflict, hunger, displacement and preventable deaths, with more than 200 million expected to need humanitarian assistance this year alone, Save the Children has warned.